Skip to main content
UK Visa Desk

Mistakes

Adult Dependent Relative visa: the mistakes that get Indian files refused

Direct answer

8 mistakes get Indian Adult Dependent Relative visa files refused more than any rule does, starting with a doctor's report dated the same month as the application, with no earlier records and arguing that the son or daughter can easily afford to look after you in the uk. Each one below with what it costs and the fix, beside the paragraphs officers cite.

Reviewed by UK Visa Desk counselling team, Visa counsellors, Pro Lifeset Overseas Pvt Ltd, Patiala. Licence 849/DC/PTA/PLA/LC-3/2024. Last verified .

From the desk

Mistakes we see

From files Indian applicants have brought to the desk after a refusal, most frequent first. The fix is what the reapplication must show.

Mistakes in Indian files, their consequence and the fix
The mistakeWhat it costsThe fix
A doctor's report dated the same month as the application, with no earlier recordsThe officer treats the report as prepared for the visa and gives it little weight, so the care need under ADR 5.1 is not proved.Build the file from years of treatment: specialist letters, discharge summaries, prescriptions and bills, then add a current assessment.
Arguing that the son or daughter can easily afford to look after you in the UKUnder ADR 5.2 the sponsor's money shows care is affordable in India, so the application is refused.Focus on availability and suitability: show what care was tried in India and why it did not meet the need.
A general practitioner's letter instead of specialist evidenceThe letter describes a condition but not a need for help with everyday tasks, so ADR 5.1 is not met.Obtain reports from the treating specialist and an independent assessment of daily living needs by a geriatrician or occupational therapist.
No evidence that care in India was ever triedThe officer finds paid care is available in every Indian city and refuses under ADR 5.2.Hire or approach carers and nursing homes, keep the contracts, quotes and withdrawal or refusal letters, and explain each failure.
Applying from inside the UK after arriving as a visitorThe route requires an application from outside the UK, so it is refused, and overstaying to pursue it is a Part 9 breach.Return to India and apply from there, with the recent visit explained honestly.
Other children or siblings in India not mentionedThe officer finds that relatives nearby could provide care and refuses.List every relative in India with a statement on their circumstances and why they cannot provide daily care.
Punjabi affidavits and hospital papers without certified translationsThe documents are not considered, and the care history they describe is treated as missing.Attach certified English translations with the translator's details for every document.
No signed 5-year maintenance undertaking or no inspection reportE-ECDR.3.1 and 3.2 are not met even where the care need is accepted.Include the undertaking, 6 months of the sponsor's finances and an inspection report showing the room you will occupy.

The grounds officers cite

  • E-ECDR.2.5: care is available in India through paid carers or nursing homes, and the sponsor can afford it from the UK
  • E-ECDR.2.4: medical evidence shows a condition but not a need for help with everyday personal tasks
  • Other family members in India could provide care, and no evidence shows why they cannot
  • Sponsor's finances insufficient for 5 years of support, or the undertaking missing
  • Applicant recently visited the UK and returned, suggesting independence and that care in India was working
  • Part 9 and credibility: medical reports dated just before the application with no earlier treatment history
Appendix Adult Dependent Relative: ADR 4.1 to ADR 5.2

Adult Dependent Relative: long-term care need and care unavailable in India

The hardest family route. The officer accepted the parent is elderly or unwell but found that care is available in India (paid carers, hospitals, other relatives) and the UK sponsor could fund it from the UK. Almost all Indian ADR applications are refused on this paragraph.

What to fix: detailed medical reports describing the daily tasks the applicant cannot perform; evidence of attempts to arrange care locally and why it failed (letters from agencies, costs, the applicant's refusal of strangers due to dementia, for example); statements from every relative in India explaining why they cannot care.

Decode Appendix Adult Dependent Relative: ADR 4.1 to ADR 5.2
9.2.1

Exclusion or deportation order in force

A mandatory refusal: you were deported from the UK or formally excluded, and that order is still in force. No visa can be granted until the order is revoked.

What to fix: apply for revocation of the deportation order (normally after 10 years, earlier only in exceptional cases) with a UK regulated adviser; do not submit new visa applications while the order stands; each refusal adds to the record.

Decode 9.2.1
9.3.1

Presence not conducive to the public good

The officer considers your behaviour, character or associations make you unsuitable, for example extremism, serious dishonesty not covered by other paragraphs, or a pattern of conduct abroad. Used rarely but it is mandatory.

What to fix: obtain the full reasons (ask for the decision notice and consider a Subject Access Request); character evidence and clearance certificates; this ground usually needs legal representation.

Decode 9.3.1
9.4.1

Criminality: custodial sentence of 12 months or more, persistent offender, serious harm

A mandatory refusal for a prison sentence of 12 months or more anywhere in the world, or for repeat offending or serious-harm offences. Sentences under 12 months are considered under 9.4.2 to 9.4.5 (discretionary, with time limits for visitors).

What to fix: always declare convictions; non-disclosure leads to a 9.7.1 deception finding on top; for shorter sentences, show the time elapsed and rehabilitation evidence; get the court record and sentence length in English.

Decode 9.4.1
9.7.1

False representations or documents, or failure to disclose (mandatory where deception used)

The Home Office says something in your application was false: a fake bank statement, an edited employer letter, an undisclosed previous refusal, or a document an agent made up without telling you. 'Whether or not to the applicant's knowledge' means you are refused even if the agent did it. Where deception is found, a 10-year ban under 9.8.4 usually follows.

What to fix: get your file: Subject Access Request to UKVI for the verification notes; if a document was genuine, obtain written confirmation from the issuer and a statement from them; if an agent submitted documents without your knowledge, gather the agent's receipts, messages and a police complaint; it does not remove the finding but can matter for later applications.

Decode 9.7.1
9.7.2

False representations without proven deception (discretionary refusal)

A discretionary version: a previous application contained something false and the officer has chosen to refuse this one because of it, without a formal deception finding. The difference matters: 9.7.2 does not by itself bring the 10-year ban.

What to fix: address the earlier problem head-on in a cover letter with the correct documents; show that the current application is fully consistent with the earlier one where the earlier one was true.

Decode 9.7.2
Every refusal paragraph for this route
Our all-in filing price: ₹39,999, GST included, the same price as on lifesetoverseas.com. Home Office fees and the health surcharge are paid by you on gov.uk and shown below in rupees. No outcome is guaranteed.

Related questions

What are my realistic chances as a parent from India?

Low. The Home Office refuses most applications because it finds paid care is available in India. Cases that succeed usually involve dementia, severe disability or conditions needing a family member rather than a paid carer, with years of medical records. We will tell you honestly before you pay £3,635.

Does my son or daughter's income help?

Only for the maintenance test. For the care test it works against you: if they can afford a carer in India, the rule says care is affordable there. The question is whether suitable care exists at all, not whether they would rather you lived with them.

Can I apply from inside the UK after arriving as a visitor?

No. The rules require an application from outside the UK. Applying in-country is refused, and overstaying to do so damages every future application.

All 8 questions
  • Punjab licence: 849/DC/PTA/PLA/LC-3/2024valid to 22 July 2029
  • CIN: U52291PB2024PTC060508Pro Lifeset Overseas Pvt Ltd